The clinic smells faintly of some medicated oil and old paper. Aarav, Rohan, and Kabir step in, the mysterious book in Aarav’s hand. Dr. Azad, seated with a cup of tea and notes on his desk, looks up with recognition.
Dr. Azad: Back again, with more fire from Charaka, I presume?
Kabir (smiling): You know us too well, Uncle. We just read the chapter on how the body treats food, and about this therapeutic emesis. It was fascinating but puzzling.
Aarav: How does vomiting actually happen? They described saliva, mucus, juices, and bile coming up one after another. Is that how the body really works?
Dr. Azad: Vomiting is a reflex action controlled by a part of the brain called the vomiting center in the medulla. When triggered, the diaphragm and abdominal muscles contract, the stomach squeezes upward, and the contents are forced out. What Charaka’s students described, the order of saliva, mucus, stomach juices, then bile, is remarkably close to what happens in reality. Their observation was keen.
Rohan: And what about that fruit paste they used? Madana-phala?
Dr. Azad: Yes, its scientific name is Randia spinosa. It is actually a natural emetic. Substances in it irritate the stomach lining and stimulate the vomiting center. Even today we use this while administering Vamana-karma. So when Charaka gave it to his students, it was both experience and a way to make them observe digestion stage by stage. That is why he called Vamana a teacher.
Aarav: But to be frank, inducing vomiting purposefully sounds a bit illogical.
Dr. Azad: You are right to feel cautious, Aarav. For many years, substances such as syrup of ipecac were kept in homes and used in emergency departments to induce vomiting after accidental poisoning. But today, therapeutic emesis is no longer a routine or recommended practice in mainstream medicine because better alternatives are available. However, in systems such as Yoga and Āyurveda, therapeutic emesis, Vamana-karma, is still practiced in carefully selected contexts. A few studies have suggested that it may offer certain benefits, though these studies are small in scale and preliminary in nature. This remains an area that requires more rigorous and systematic research before firm conclusions can be drawn.
Kabir: I found Charaka’s approach clever: making the body show its secrets by throwing things out.
Dr. Azad: Exactly. It was both medical and educational. Now, remember how Charaka said that certain diseases rise in certain seasons? Do you think that still makes sense today?
Aarav: He said Kapha rises in spring, right? He said cases of wheezing are seen in spring.
Dr. Azad: Yes, many people suffer from allergic bronchial asthma in the spring. Why? Because pollen from new blossoms triggers their hypersensitive airways. The result is wheezing. That is not very different from what Charaka described as Kapha disorders.
Rohan: And he said Vāta increases in the rainy season. What about that?
Dr. Azad: During the rains, we still see neurological problems more often. Viral infections like encephalitis often peak in monsoon months in our country. That matches the ancient note of Vāta-vyādhi.
Kabir: And in post-monsoon season? He mentioned Pitta problems.
Dr. Azad: Indeed. In hospitals we see more cases of bleeding peptic ulcers and acid-peptic disease around that time. Cold weather seems to affect acid secretion and blood supply in the stomach. This fits Charaka’s observation of Amla-pitta: burning, sour belching, and sometimes even vomiting blood.
Aarav (thoughtful): Does Charaka explicitly say this in his book? Does he describe how and when a theory is to be modified?
Dr. Azad: Well, this mysterious author has imaginatively introduced this in his book. For example, Amla-Pitta is an entity that we encounter in later texts. However, it is consistent with Ayurvedic thought. In the original text you do not get such explicit explanation of theory modification, though you get many examples. Such modification would amount to a ‘conventionalist stratagem’ in the Popperian sense.
Kabir: Now this is new to me. What is that?
Dr. Azad: Karl Popper described such adjustments as conventionalist stratagems, ways of protecting a theory from falsification even when counterevidence exists. The claim that Kapha solidifies in winter and then liquefies in spring because of exposure to the sun is a typical example of inventing an explanation to fit what is observed. Popper would have considered this an instance of “theory rescue” and taken it as a sign of weakness in the theory. However, many other philosophers argue that Popper’s criterion is too strict to apply universally in judging scientific theories. Let us take this up on another occasion; it will need some homework on your side.
Kabir: Sure! This is interesting!
Rohan: I think ancient physicians were careful observers who noted real patterns, even if our modern explanations differ.
Dr. Azad: Precisely. They worked with what they could observe: vomiting sequences, stool colour, seasonal illness patterns. They built theories from repeated clinical observation.
Rohan: Then should we take those stages, Madhura, Amla, Kaṭu, literally?
Dr. Azad: No. They are not chemical stages. They are experiential categories. Madhura corresponds to chewing and salivation, Amla to gastric digestion with acid, Kaṭu to intestinal gas and waste. It is an experiential way to organize observations.
Kabir: Uncle, in modern physiology, how exactly does digestion proceed?
Dr. Azad: Digestion begins the moment food enters the mouth. Saliva moistens and partly breaks down starch with the enzyme salivary amylase. Once swallowed, the food bolus moves through the esophagus into the stomach. There, gastric glands release hydrochloric acid and pepsin, which denature proteins and cut them into smaller fragments. The stomach also churns the food into a semi-liquid form called chyme.
Aarav: And what happens when this chyme leaves the stomach?
Dr. Azad: It enters the small intestine, where most digestion and absorption occur. The pancreas secretes enzymes like trypsin, amylase, and lipase that act on proteins, carbohydrates, and fats. At the same time, bile from the liver emulsifies fats so they can be broken down more effectively. Nutrients are then absorbed across the intestinal wall into the blood or lymph. The large intestine follows, where water is absorbed and gut microbes act on the remaining matter before stool is finally expelled.
Kabir: So would it be correct to say that the ancient three stages roughly correspond to these steps?
Dr. Azad: In a sense, yes. Madhura reflects the pleasing and softening of food in the mouth, Amla parallels the acidic breakdown in the stomach, and Kaṭu corresponds to the drying and expulsion in the intestines. The categories are not biochemical, but the underlying observations map well to modern physiology.
Aarav: Charaka says people with dry mouth cannot perceive taste. Is that true?
Dr. Azad: Yes. Xerostomia (dry mouth), whether caused by salivary gland hypofunction, medications, or systemic conditions, is strongly associated with impaired taste. Several studies report that patients with xerostomia frequently complain of loss of taste intensity, difficulty identifying flavours, and reduced enjoyment of food.
Kabir: Ah, that is quite interesting! But why is that so?
Dr. Azad: Taste depends on saliva, which dissolves food particles and carries them to the taste buds on the tongue. Saliva also keeps the mouth moist and the taste buds healthy so they can work properly.
Aarav: These details must have been beyond Charaka’s imagination, I am sure. Yet, he was right!
Dr. Azad: Well said. So Āyurveda’s strength is in observation and reasoning. It is intellectual history. It shows how humans tried to make sense of the body before microscopes and biochemistry. And the fact that some patterns still hold, like asthma in spring or bile affecting stool colour, reminds us that careful observation, even without modern tools, can reveal enduring truths.
The boys leave the clinic after thanking Dr. Azad. On their way home, they wonder if they too could construct a theory of blood circulation or respiration using only the tools and methods that would have been accessible to Charaka.
####
Leave a Reply